When it comes to building a strong and impressive back, Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows are two exercises that often come to mind. Both exercises are popular choices among weightlifters and bodybuilders, but which one is more effective?
Pendlay Rows, named after the legendary strength coach Glenn Pendlay, are a type of barbell row that emphasizes explosive pulling from the floor. Bent Over Rows, on the other hand, involve a more upright position with the torso parallel to the ground, and emphasize a wider range of motion.
In this blog post, we will dive deep into the key differences between pendlay rows vs bent over rows. We’ll examine the muscle groups worked by each exercise, the pros and cons of each movement pattern, and provide guidance on how to determine which exercise is more suitable for your goals. So, whether you’re a beginner or an experienced lifter looking to switch up your routine, this post will help you decide which exercise to incorporate into your training program.
What is Pendlay Rows?
This dead stop technique requires a full reset of the body position and engages the muscles in a different way than other rowing exercises.
To perform Pendlay Rows, you start by loading a barbell with the desired weight and positioning yourself in front of it with your feet shoulder-width apart. You then reach down and grasp the bar with a pronated grip (palms facing down) slightly wider than shoulder-width. Keeping your back straight and core engaged, you explosively pull the bar up towards your chest until it touches your lower chest or upper abdomen. After reaching the top of the movement, you lower the bar back to the starting position, with the barbell resting on the ground between each repetition. Pendlay Rows primarily target the back muscles, including the lats, traps, and rhomboids, as well as the biceps and forearms.
What is Bent Over Rows?
Bent Over Rows are a popular exercise for developing upper body strength, particularly in the back muscles. To perform Bent Over Rows, you start by standing with your feet shoulder-width apart, holding a barbell or dumbbells with an overhand grip (palms facing down). You then bend your knees slightly and hinge at your hips, leaning forward until your upper body is roughly parallel to the ground.
From this position, you pull the weight up towards your chest or abdomen, keeping your elbows close to your body and squeezing your shoulder blades together at the top of the movement. After reaching the top, you slowly lower the weight back down to the starting position, making sure to maintain good form and control throughout the exercise. Bent Over Rows target the back muscles, including the lats, rhomboids, and traps, as well as the biceps and forearms. They are a versatile exercise that can be performed with a variety of equipment, including barbells, dumbbells, and resistance bands.
Read more about Deca Injection
Pendlay Rows vs Bent Over Rows Comparisons
Muscle Groups Worked
Both Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows target the back muscles, including the lats, rhomboids, and traps. However, the two exercises differ in terms of the muscles they emphasize and the degree of activation.
Pendlay Rows place a greater emphasis on the mid-back muscles, including the rhomboids and traps. This is because the dead stop technique used in Pendlay Rows requires a more explosive pulling movement from the ground, which engages these muscles to a greater extent. Additionally, Pendlay Rows tend to have a more limited range of motion compared to Bent Over Rows, which can further increase the activation of the mid-back muscles.
Bent Over Rows, on the other hand, emphasize the lower back muscles to a greater extent. This is because the bent-over position of the exercise places greater stress on the erector spinae muscles, which help to maintain spinal stability during the movement. Bent Over Rows also tend to have a longer range of motion compared to Pendlay Rows, which can increase the overall muscle activation and recruitment.
Movement Patterns
Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows also differ in terms of their movement patterns. Pendlay Rows involve a more explosive pulling movement from the ground, with the barbell lifted from a dead stop each rep. This technique requires a full reset of the body position and engages the muscles in a different way than other rowing exercises. Pendlay Rows tend to have a shorter range of motion compared to Bent Over Rows, as the barbell is lifted to the lower chest or upper abdomen.
Bent Over Rows involve a more continuous pulling movement, with the barbell or dumbbells pulled towards the chest or abdomen while maintaining a bent-over position. This exercise emphasizes a wider range of motion, with the weight lifted from the starting position to the top of the movement.
The choice of exercise will depend on individual goals and preferences. Pendlay Rows may be more suitable for explosive strength and power development, while Bent Over Rows may be better for overall back muscle development and endurance.
Exercise Technique and Form
Proper technique and form are crucial for both Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows to avoid injury and maximize results. In Pendlay Rows, it is important to maintain a neutral spine and engage the core muscles throughout the exercise. The barbell should be lifted explosively from the ground towards the lower chest or upper abdomen, with the elbows close to the body and the shoulders pulled back and down at the top of the movement. It is important to avoid rounding the back or lifting with the arms, as this can lead to injury.
For Bent Over Rows, it is important to maintain a neutral spine and engage the core muscles throughout the exercise. The weight should be pulled towards the chest or abdomen in a controlled manner, with the elbows close to the body and the shoulders pulled back and down at the top of the movement. It is important to avoid rounding the back or using momentum to lift the weight, as this can also lead to injury.
Read more about Pendlay Rows vs Bent Over Rows
Variation and Progression
Both Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows offer a variety of variations and progressions to keep workouts challenging and prevent plateauing. For Pendlay Rows, variations can include changing the grip width, using dumbbells instead of a barbell, or incorporating pauses at various points during the movement. For Bent Over Rows, variations can include changing the grip width, using different equipment, such as resistance bands or a cable machine, or incorporating unilateral (single-arm) movements.
Progression for both exercises can involve increasing the weight, increasing the number of sets and repetitions, or decreasing the rest time between sets. It is important to progress gradually and with proper form to avoid injury and ensure maximum results.
Injury Prevention and Safety
Like any exercise, Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows come with a risk of injury if proper form and technique are not maintained. Common injuries associated with both exercises include lower back pain, shoulder injuries, and wrist injuries.
To prevent injuries, it is important to start with lighter weights and gradually increase the load as strength and technique improve. It is also important to maintain a neutral spine and engage the core muscles throughout the exercise. Avoid using momentum to lift the weight and do not lift with the arms or around the back.
If you have a history of back or shoulder injuries, it is important to consult with a healthcare professional or qualified personal trainer before attempting these exercises.
Suitability for Different Goals
The choice of exercise will depend on individual goals and preferences. Pendlay Rows may be more suitable for explosive strength and power development, while Bent Over Rows may be better for overall back muscle development and endurance. Both exercises can be effective for building back strength and muscle, but the choice of exercise will depend on individual goals, equipment availability, and personal preference.
In general, if you are looking to develop overall back muscle size and endurance, Bent Over Rows may be a better choice. If you are looking to develop explosive strength and power in the mid-back muscles, Pendlay Rows may be more suitable.
Incorporating Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows into Your Training Program
Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows can be incorporated into a well-rounded training program to develop back strength and muscle. Here are some tips for incorporating these exercises into your routine:
- Determine your goals: Before incorporating Pendlay Rows or Bent Over Rows into your training program, it is important to determine your goals. If you are looking to develop explosive strength and power, Pendlay Rows may be more suitable. If you are looking to develop overall back muscle size and endurance, Bent Over Rows may be a better choice.
- Choose the right weight: When starting out, it is important to choose a weight that is challenging but manageable. Start with a lighter weight and gradually increase the load as strength and technique improve.
- Incorporate variations: To keep workouts challenging and prevent plateauing, it is important to incorporate variations and progressions. For Pendlay Rows, variations can include changing the grip width, using dumbbells instead of a barbell, or incorporating pauses at various points during the movement. For Bent Over Rows, variations can include changing the grip width, using different equipment, such as resistance bands or a cable machine, or incorporating unilateral (single-arm) movements.
- Schedule the exercises appropriately: Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows can be performed on separate days or on the same day as other back exercises, such as pull-ups or lat pulldowns. It is important to schedule the exercises appropriately to avoid overtraining and allow for adequate rest and recovery.
- Follow proper technique and form: Proper technique and form are crucial for both Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows to avoid injury and maximize results. Maintain a neutral spine and engage the core muscles throughout the exercise. Avoid rounding the back, lifting with the arms, or using momentum to lift the weight.
Incorporating Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows into your training program can help you develop a stronger and more muscular back. By following proper technique and form, gradually increasing the load and intensity, and incorporating variations and progressions, you can achieve maximum results and avoid injury.
Read more about Master the Barbell Pull Up
Conclusion
Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows are both effective exercises for building back strength and muscle. While both exercises target the back muscles, they differ in terms of the muscles they emphasize, the degree of activation, and the movement patterns involved. The choice of exercise will depend on individual goals and preferences.
Pendlay Rows place more emphasis on the mid-back muscles, making them more suitable for explosive strength and power development. Bent Over Rows, on the other hand, emphasize the lower back muscles to a greater extent, making them better for overall back muscle development and endurance.
To incorporate Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows into your training program, it is important to follow proper technique and form, gradually increase the load and intensity, and incorporate variations and progressions to prevent plateauing. By incorporating these exercises into a well-rounded training program, you can develop a stronger and more muscular back.
In conclusion, both Pendlay Rows and Bent Over Rows are effective exercises for building back strength and muscle. The choice of exercise will depend on individual goals and preferences, and both exercises can be incorporated into a well-rounded training program to achieve maximum results.